By Nicolas Petros KapartiCyprus in the EU's crosshairs for surveillance Before the Parliamentary Committee on Legal Affairs today in the presence of the Attorney General Reactions from EPP MEPs Recommendations from PEGA members for an in-depth examination of Cyprus - Final conclusion by summer, says MEP Stelios Kouloglou to the Cyprus Times
Cyprus is being targeted by the European Union as a "main hub" for the export of surveillance software following the publication yesterday of the preliminary report of the European Parliament's committee of inquiry PEGA, with its members recommending an in-depth investigation into our country and the parties entering the trenches.
According to the report's rapporteur Sophie in 't Veld, the two most important issues in the case of Cyprus are indications that the country is a major export hub, and that there has been surveillance of citizens with such software. "We have indications that spyware has been used against citizens. But I think what is more worrying in Cyprus is (that it is) the main hub for spyware exports," he said after the release of the preliminary report.
- HTTPS:/CYPRUSTIMES.COM/POLITIKI/EIS...-KYPROY-GIA-LOGISMIKA-PARAKOLOYTHISIS-I-PEGA/
- "Cyprus is a centre for the export of surveillance software". The draft report of PEGA
When is the final report expected
Speaking to the Cyprus Times about the findings of the preliminary report, the Greek MEP and member of the PEGA committee, Stelios Kouloglou, said that there should definitely be an in-depth investigation in Cyprus, noting that "in Cyprus we were not given any substantial answer".
"We asked for the Stephanou report to be made public and it was not, we learned that the brother of the Assistant Attorney General had relations with the Israelis who started the whole story, we learned that the same Assistant Attorney General provided legal services to the Israelis and we learned that the van case was closed without any substantial answers. Therefore, it goes without saying that this must be done."
Asked about the next steps, Mr. Kouloglou explained that the report that has been made public is a draft and that other countries - Hungary and possibly Spain - will be visited in the next period and then a final conclusion will be reached, which will be submitted to the plenary of the European Parliament for approval by the summer.
Mr. Kouloglou also indicated that if the final conclusion is adopted by the plenary, it will have a "political weight" and that if it is found that there are serious problems with the rule of law, the independence of the judiciary, the media, other procedures will be launched regarding the violation of the rule of law by member states.
Asked to comment on how the conclusion that Cyprus is a "hub for the export of surveillance software" was reached, Mr.Kouloglou replied that: "from the briefings we had, even from the official bodies, this conclusion was reached, given that these companies have not been audited by the Cypriot state. There is a volume of exports made for these systems despite the fact that they operate in the grey zone between legality and illegality. From what we have been told there are 32 relevant companies of which 10 are active and deal with communications and communications hijacking in general and 3-4 of them deal entirely with corresponding software."
Therefore, "Cyprus has turned into a permanent market exhibition of surveillance systems," the PEGA Committee member underlined.
Parliament
The issue of Cyprus' involvement in the production or distribution of software that could be used for illegal surveillance is being put before the Parliamentary Legal Affairs Committee today.
The ex-officio examination of the matter will take place following a recommendation by AKEL MPs and the Attorney General, the Minister of Energy, the Minister of Justice, the Deputy Minister of Research, the Chief of Police and the Commissioner for Personal Data Protection, among others, have been invited to attend.
The whole debate is expected to take place in a tense atmosphere, due to reports in the preliminary report on the possible use of such software by the government itself and following the criticisms made before the PEGA Committee - last week - in Parliament by an AKEL MP, Aristos Damianou, about party transactions with companies or individuals active in the production and/or export of dual-use software, indicating that DISY and the Cabinet should answer a number of questions.
However, for its part, DISY clarified through a written statement - after the publication of the PEGA Committee's preliminary report - that it "has not the slightest involvement and is the first to want the full clarification of the case of surveillance".
While at the same time he speaks of political expediency by opposition parties, noting that there is not the slightest accusation against Averof Neophytou.
"Wave" of reactions from PEGA members
From there, the press conference held by Mrs In 't Veld and the views expressed in it provoked a strong reaction from members of PEGAPEGA from the ELK (the political group to which the governments in Greece and Cyprus belong), with the group's MEP coordinator on the committee Juan Ignacio Zoido expressing dissatisfaction through a letter to PEGA members.
Responding to the reactions raised, PEGA
committee chairman Jörun Lennaers made it clear that the draft report "is not the final version and cannot at this stage be taken as the conclusions or position of the PEGA committee as a whole."
Mr. Lennaers also explained that "all members of the PEGA committee will have the opportunity to submit amendments to the draft report" and that only the final report and the recommendations of the committee of inquiry, as adopted at the end of its mandate, represent the position of the European Parliament as a whole.
Preliminary report 'burns' Cyprus
As reported in an earlier Cyprus Times report, the 13-page chapter of the preliminary report - which concerns Cyprus - states that our country is "an important European export hub for the surveillance industry", adding that "on paper there is a strong legal framework, including EU rules, but in practice, Cyprus is an attractive place for companies selling surveillance technologies."
What the PEGA Committee proposes for Cyprus
Finally, it is worth mentioning that in its preliminary report the PEGA Committee recommends, among other things, Cyprus to proceed without delay with the EU-wide ban on the sale, acquisition, transfer and use of spyware, which can be lifted on a case-by-case basis if four conditions are met.
These conditions relate to the full investigation and handling by the competent authorities of all alleged abuses of such software, the proven implementation of a legislative framework in line with international standards, the commitment of Member States to consent to requests by Europol to investigate such cases, and the suspension of all export licences that do not comply with the Dual-use Regulation. The Commission itself will be responsible for monitoring these conditions.
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs to Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source