The CIA gets its revenge After failing to predict the 9/11 attacks saw its prestige tarnished 20 years later, the US intelligence agencies are back on the winning track. its agents "saw" Putin's invasion before it happened and killed the al-Qaeda leader
After the 9/11 terrorist attacks and its failure to predict or prevent them, the CIA has seen its prestige tarnished. It took two decades before it began to restore it. A few months ago it persistently warned about the Russian invasion of Ukraine, about Vladimir Putin's belligerent intentions
And a few days ago it achieved something it had been trying for a long time: the neutralisation of al-Qaeda leader Ayman al-Zahrawi, Osama bin Laden's successor. His assassination was carried out with an unguided, bladed missile - there was no explosion and no collateral damage. This is the 'revenge of the CIA', which shows that it has changed course and is 'returning to success', writes the 'Nouvel Observateur' in its tribute to the US secret services.
The "Company" - as the novelist Robert Littel has renamed it - recently reinforced its image by revealing to the world Vladimir Putin's decision to invade Ukraine long before Russian troops set out for the Ukrainian border. This was thanks to a spy inside the Kremlin, in Putin's inner circle.
"The identity of this informer, whose existence is not disputed, is the best protected secret on the planet," a French intelligence official confides, adding: "The CIA owes him so much! Thanks to him, the US intelligence agency - which celebrates its 75th anniversary this year - has regained its credibility in a matter of months and restored the disastrous image it had created in previous years."
Until recently this did not seem possible as the CIA fell from one mistake to another - for the first time it had accumulated so many failures since it was created in 1947 to "fight communist expansionism."
Until recently this did not seem possible as the CIA fell from one mistake to another - for the first time it had accumulated so many failures since it was created in 1947 to "fight communist expansionism. From the 1960s it took part in many overthrows of governments and supported coups, particularly in Latin America.
After the break-up of the Soviet Union in 1991, some called for its dissolution. No one could accurately describe its mission after the end of the Cold War.
The attacks of 11 September 2001 gave it a reason to exist: the fight against jihadists. However, in this secret war for which she was not prepared, she went astray once again. The list of its mistakes over the last twenty years is endless: lying about the existence of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, torture of prisoners in secret prisons around the world, large-scale interception of communications and data of American citizens revealed by Edward Snowden. So many methods contrary to the values she was supposed to uphold.
Her obsession with preventing another 9/11, writes Vincent Javert in the French magazine, "blinded her completely to developments in the world. She did not see the Arab Spring uprisings coming in 2011. These fiascos tarnished its image to such an extent that Donald Trump publicly mocked its executives, speaking ironically in late 2019 of their 'mismanagement' and 'lack of intelligence'."
After the invasion of Ukraine, critics fell silent, the French journalist continues. In early 2022, shortly before the attack began, the CIA "was better informed about Putin's intentions than the Russian intelligence bosses. One scene says it all. On February 21, three days before the largest military operation in Europe since 1945, Vladimir Putin convened his Security Council: in front of tens of millions of viewers, he asked one by one the heads of military units and intelligence services what should be done in Ukraine. The director of the SVR, the secret services, Sergei Naryshkin, lost it and was reprimanded by the Russian President. But the CIA knew. And several days earlier."
Three weeks before the attack, journalists were invited to a rare briefing at CIA headquarters. Intelligence officials showed them satellite photos of Russian military deployment on the Ukrainian border and outlined the invasion scenario, exactly what Putin was trying to implement.
They went so far as to give a date for the start of operations: it would be a day too cold for the tanks to get stuck, right after the end of the Beijing Olympics, which concluded on Sunday, February 20.
Thanks to the spy in Putin's inner circle but also to the NSA (National Security Agency) and the NRO (National Reconnaissance Office), the agency that controls the spy satellites, the CIA predicted correctly.
In the hours before the invasion they were able to provide the White House with information of rare accuracy. On the evening of February 23, Moscow was still swearing that American predictions were nothing but manipulation. Yet the US diplomatic chief, Anthony Blinken, asserts that this "major attack" will take place "before the end of the night". The "special military operation", as the Kremlin calls it, began a few hours later, at the freezing dawn of February 23rd to 24th, four days after the end of the Olympic Games in China.
At that time in Europe, things are not easy. By November 2021, CIA envoys were touring the capitals of the Old Continent to explain that an invasion of Ukraine was being prepared. They meet with the Italian, German, British and French secret services. Together with them, the Americans form an informal group - known as the "Five" - which meets regularly.
However, the information the spy gave to the Kremlin is not presented to them. It is shared only with Anglo-Saxon allies, the only ones they consider truly reliable: Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United Kingdom. Poorly informed, the authorities in Paris, Berlin and Rome were sceptical about the certainties expressed by the American envoys. They believe that the Americans are overinterpreting certain facts, that Putin is bluffing, that he will not dare cross the border."
"The Americans said the Russians were going to attack, they were right," the chief of staff of the French troops, Thierry Bourguard, later admitted to Le Monde. "Our services probably thought that conquering Ukraine would have a monstrous cost and that the Russians had other options" to bring down the regime of Volodymyr Zelensky. The mistake would cost the job to General Eric Vidot, head of France's Military Intelligence Directorate, who was fired three weeks later.
This blunder is largely explained by lies in the CIA's past. Particularly those told to justify the 2003 invasion of Iraq. These misleading lies announced 20 years ago by an arrogant American administration have left a deep mark on the allies of the United States. All Europeans remember the intervention of George Bush's Secretary of State, Colin Powell, before the United Nations Security Council in February 2003.
The famous four-star general presented the world with the CIA's "indisputable proof" of the existence of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. Then-CIA Director George Tenet was sitting right behind him as a guarantee. Yet Powell was fooled and so was everyone else. All the evidence presented to the world by the general, all of it, will be proven false.
In the years of cyber spies
In the new digital world, the CIA must discover a new way of operating, says director William Burns.
In 2014, Chinese cyber spies hacked into US administration computers and found the names, fingerprints or previous jobs of 22 million public employees. By cross-referencing this data, they were able to identify many CIA officers. All US agents stationed in China were urgently recalled. After these files were shared with the Russians, the CIA had to recall its agents in Moscow as well.
More recently, an entire network of informants was uncovered. According to the New York Times, the CIA sent a top-secret cable in October 2021 to all its stations around the world, informing them that a large number of sources had been captured or even executed in China, Iran and Russia. How were they identified? Probably thanks to the massive deployment of remote identification systems (facial, voice, eye, etc.). The proliferation of biometric techniques makes it very difficult, if not impossible, to protect spies.
To deal with this situation, the CIA now has a digital innovation department. However, according to most experts, modernization is very slow, especially in terms of artificial intelligence. Burns revealed that 1/3 of the agency's employees now work in cyberspace. But the best in the field are most attracted to the private sector and are reluctant to join an organization often seen as old-fashioned or evil.
To attract them, the Corporation aired, in 2020, the first TV spot in its history. And last March, it opened a state-of-the-art 4,000-square-foot fitness center. Will that be enough to attract the spies of tomorrow?
William Burns, the new chief
The restructuring of the CIA also needed a new chief. The 66-year-old diplomat William Burns, who served as undersecretary of state from 2011 to 2014, was named at the helm of the agency last March. He is so highly regarded by the Senate Intelligence Committee establishment that it unanimously approved him. Bill Burns, who is fluent in Russian, was ambassador to Moscow from 2005 to 2008, a period during which he met with Vladimir Putin several times. In his 2019 book "The Back Channel," which recounts the highlights of his career, he describes the Russian leader as "a very combustible combination of ambition and insecurity." Three years before the invasion of Ukraine, Burns adds, almost prophetically, "Over the years, his appetite for risk increased as his power grew and his circle of advisers shrank."
In early November 2021, when it became clear that Putin was preparing military intervention, Joe Biden sent Burns to Moscow to speak with the Russian leader. Away from microphones and cameras, the CIA boss let him know that he knew every detail of his plan to invade Ukraine. And warned him of the economic sanctions they would inflict. To no avail.
The diplomat, who also speaks perfect Arabic and French, is a man of covert missions. In 2003, after the fall of Saddam Hussein, he persuaded Colonel Gaddafi to abandon his nuclear program. He was also the man who laid the groundwork for the 2015 Iran nuclear deal. Since Biden's election, some have called William Burns the shadow secretary of state. He is the one the U.S. president sends on dangerous missions. After Moscow, Biden sent him to Riyadh in May to meet with the Saudi kingdom's strongman, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman ("MBS"), to prepare for Biden's visit to Saudi Arabia.
Burns insists there is an urgent need to radically transform an organization that employs more than 20,000 people worldwide (the exact number is classified). Because, he says, "America is going through one of those moments of strategic transition that only happen two or three times a century." His obsessions? The artificial intelligence revolution and, above all, the rise of Xi Jinping's power in China. Despite Putin's military adventurism, China remains for him the greatest geopolitical challenge and he sees the possibility of an invasion of Taiwan.
Source: "TA NEA"/in.gr
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source