What's new

[Cyprus Times] In plenary session, a proposal to postpone the opening of the Supreme Constitutional-Supreme Court by six months

dikastirio.jpg

The Legal Affairs Committee has given a "green light" to a proposal in the Plenary to postpone the opening of the Supreme Constitutional Court by six months

The Legal Affairs Committee has given a "green light", Justice and Public Order of the House of Representatives to forward for a vote in the House of Representatives the amendment to the Law on Courts to postpone the effective date of the reopening of the Supreme Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court to July 1, 2023, instead of January 1, 2023, as envisaged.

The proposed law was tabled by the Legal Affairs Committee at the request of the President of the Supreme Court, Anthony Liatsos. Liatsos informed the MPs that the reasons for the postponement of the date relate to the staffing of the courts, as there are pending appointments to be filled in the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Courts, which will lead to vacancies in the courts of first instance. He estimated that it would take 6-7 months to complete the process of recruitment and training of judges and therefore asked that the entry into force of the reopening of the two supreme courts be postponed to July 1.

In addition, the recruitment of administrative staff is also pending, which is also estimated to be completed by then, the Supreme Court President said.

Minister of Justice and Public Order, Stefi Drakou and General Prosecutor, Savvas Angelides, agreed with the proposal of the President of the Supreme Court to postpone the date. On the other hand, the Bar Association disagreed, with its representative citing the serious possibility of creating legal uncertainty due to the extensions requested, while it was reported that other unforeseen issues are likely to arise. We want to guard the reform and support it as passed, he said.

The Legal Affairs Committee decided to forward the bill as a priority to the plenary for a vote.

The President of the Supreme Court raised a second issue for amendment in the Courts of Justice Act. The Act provides that the number of judges comprising the Supreme Constitutional Court shall be nine. He said that for the staffing of other courts, a maximum number of judges is provided for and not an absolute number. For example, the Supreme Court is provided for up to seven judges, the Court of Appeal up to 16. The President raised the issue of quality of justice and difficulty in finding a sufficient number of judges for staffing, so he asked that it be amended to be up to nine.

The Attorney General supported the request of the President of the Supreme Court and suggested that a minimum number of seven judges could be set as an insurance policy and that it would be at the discretion of the President concerned to staff the Court as and when required.



The Minister of Justice did not object to the matter.

The Chairman of the Committee, DISY MP, Nikos Tornaritis said that there should be consultations within the parties and if we all decide together we will submit a bill on the issue, otherwise the government will have to submit a bill.

On behalf of AKEL, MP Aristos Damianou said that on the issue of changing the number of judges, there is neither a law proposal nor a government bill and said that for the amendment to be made, the proposal must come with a government initiative. He said that if there is a consensus, AKEL will support the proposal, but will not consent to its submission as a legislative proposal on behalf of the committee.

DIKO MP Panicos Leonidou said there is nothing official, apart from the appeal of the President of the Supreme Court. Not to give the impression that we are making amendments now to something we passed after much consultation and pressure, he noted.

Charalambos

Theopeptou, President of the Ecologists' Movement, said the issue should be discussed when it arises.

In statements after the commission, the Minister of Justice said the Supreme Court has the greatest responsibility in terms of implementing judicial reform and therefore the Supreme Court's request for an extension of the effective date "could only be granted to ensure that the courts are properly staffed."

He added that these are 26 posts for new judges and administrative cuts that need to be made and there should be an opportunity to get this implementation of the reform right. Responding to a question, he said that this is the last extension granted at the request of the Supreme Court. It is a difficult and arduous task and we should not risk depopulation of the provincial courts or improper staffing of the other courts. The Supreme Court is the best judge in the matter and we must responsibly listen to its views, Drakou said.

On the second request of the President of the Supreme Court, the Minister said "we must be given time to listen to the political forces, to consult with each other and we as a Government will listen and take into account both the request of the Supreme Court and the views of the political forces and as always we will synthesize and find a solution.

The Chairman of the Legal Affairs Committee, Nikos Tornaritis, in his statements said that the Supreme Court of the Republic of Cyprus has the exclusive constitutional responsibility and duty of implementing provisions, laws and the operation of the courts. We will proceed to the Plenary of the Parliament with this request, which is submitted unanimously by the Supreme Court. He added that since the Government and the Attorney General are in agreement, we accept this request.

AKEL MP Aristos Damianou said in a statement that since the Supreme Court requests and the government agrees with an extension in the implementation of the justice reform, neither the House of Representatives as a whole, nor we as AKEL could act differently.

"At the same time, of course, in no oppositional mood, I have to say the following: In all the years that preceded, even in the months leading up to the passing of the reform, we warned that the timetable that had been set and the risk of depleting the courts of presidents who would have to be transferred to the new Court of Appeal was a substantial problem that had to be answered convincingly," he said.

"It was not answered convincingly, haste had been shown and dithyrambs and celebrations were adopted for the passage and implementation of the reform and today, a few days before the implementation of the process for the separation of the Supreme Court into a High Court and a Supreme Constitutional Court inevitably and inevitably and predictably, the Supreme Court and the Government are demanding an extension in the implementation. We will give the extension but the sloppiness in the handling of the matter by the Government and the Ministry of Justice responsible is on record," he concluded.

Source: CNA


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top