"Out of all logic" Harry's position, says the Audit ServiceThe Audit Service responds to the issue of reduced VAT on first homes and what the former Minister of Finance Harris Georgiades said.
As noted, among other things, "either deliberately or out of ignorance, the provisions of the legislation are distorted".
Furthermore, it underlines that the Service "rejects as beyond all reason the position of the former Minister of Finance."
At the same time, it underlines that it adheres to the position that the former Tax Inspector illegally and improperly allowed the use of the benefit by the investors of the KEP. "We are sounding the alarm on the new Tax Commissioner in relation to future cases."
In detail. Harry Georgiades that supposedly there was no loss on the issue of reduced VAT on first homes, and because in our opinion, either intentionally or out of ignorance (both of which are a cause for concern due to the 8-year Minister's status) the provisions of the legislation are being distorted, we quote the relevant provisions verbatim.
Law of 2011 (L.129(I)/2011)
[TD]
Law of 2012 (L.73(I)/2012)
[/TD]
[TR]
[TD]"beneficiary person" means any natural person who:[/P](i) has reached the age of eighteen on the date of applying for a reduced rate for the construction or delivery of a dwelling.
(ii) is a citizen of the Republic or of any other Member State of the European Union and is permanently resident in the Republic;
(iii) has no other residence in the Republic;
[/TD][/TD]
[TD]"beneficiary person" means any natural person who:(i) has attained the eighteenth (18th) year of age on the date of applying for a reduced rate for the construction or delivery of a dwelling;
(ii) acquires a dwelling for use as his/her principal and permanent place of residence in the Republic
(iii) does not have any other residence in the Republic, which it has acquired through the application of a reduced VAT rate;[/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
Therefore, the 2012 Law, firstly, allowed the benefit to be granted to third country nationals, and secondly, the requirement for permanent establishment was replaced by the requirement to acquire a residence for use as a principal and permanent place of residence in the Republic. This provision remains to this day.
Permanent establishment is essentially equivalent to the so-called "domicile" and obviously constitutes a stronger link than "permanent residence" since, in addition to actual establishment, it also encompasses the intention of the natural person to have the country as a permanent residence for an indefinite period of time. In contrast, permanent residence (e.g. of a worker or a student in a foreign country) does not involve an intention to stay in that country indefinitely.
Our Office rejects as irrational the position of the former Minister of Finance that the phrase in the existing (since 2012) legislation, which requires that a residence be acquired "for use as a principal and permanent place of residence in the Republic", is satisfied if the residence is used as a holiday home for a few days each year.
From the continuous interventions of the former Minister of Finance, we understand that the former Tax Inspector may have been acting on the basis of instructions from his political superior, which of course does not absolve him from any of his own responsibilities since he was the legally responsible person.
In any case, we consider the issue extremely serious because it concerns not only past but also future cases.
In any case, we consider the matter extremely serious because it concerns not only past but also future cases.
The European Directive 2006/112/EC allows reduced VAT for first homes only in the context of social policy, and the House of Representatives is considering amending the legislation to set strict limits on the area and possibly the value of the dwelling for which this benefit can be granted. It is our view that, irrespective of the area or value of the dwelling, the VAT grant to persons residing outside Cyprus who acquire a residence in Cyprus, not for permanent residence but as a holiday home, can in no way be considered as a benefit under social policy.
On the basis of the above, firstly we maintain the position that the former Tax Commissioner illegally and improperly allowed the use of the benefit by the investors of the CCP, leading to a loss of hundreds of millions of euros from the public coffers, and secondly we sound the alarm to the new Tax Commissioner in relation to future cases.
And in case the position of the new Tax Commissioner will be the same as that of his predecessor, i.e. that a holiday home satisfies the requirement of the law for main and permanent residence in Cyprus, then our Service will inform the European Commission because, as we have repeatedly stressed, we consider it unacceptable in a state of law (and not lawlessness) to conceal from European institutions the real facts and facts".
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source