What's new

[Cyprus Times] Appeal to the ECHR by those convicted of the murder of Andis Hadjicostis falls on deaf ears

fonosxatzikwsti.jpg

The rights of the convicts in the Hatzikostis murder case were not violated, says the ECHR

There was no violation of the rights of the convicts Gregory Xenophontos, Tasos Krasopoulos and Elena Skordelis during the trial of the case of the murder of Andis Hadjikostis, based on Article 6§1 of the Convention on the Right to a Fair Trial, the European Court of Human Rights ruled on Tuesday.


Specifically, the ECHR ruled by a majority of 6 to 1 that the rights of the three applicants were not violated due to the use of accomplice testimony for the first instance decision. The judges also decided unanimously that there was no violation of the same article of the European Convention on Human Rights in relation to the duration of the judicial proceedings. The Court's judgment also records the dissenting opinion expressed by Judge Giorgos Sergidis.

The applicants appealed to the ECHR on 21 November and 1 December 2016, which was asked to rule on whether a trial can be considered "fair" within the meaning of Article 6 of the Convention if it results in a conviction based to a decisive degree on accomplice testimony.

For its part, the Court says that it does not identify any violation resulting from a conviction on the basis of accomplice testimony which was not the result of an agreement and which accomplice was later placed in the witness protection programme and was not prosecuted.

The ECtHR also accepts the finding of the Cypriot courts that there was no agreement between the accomplice and the prosecution authorities. It refers to Phanos Hadjigeorgiou by his initials, saying that he had confessed and turned in the applicants out of remorse, without receiving any promise in return. The Attorney General's decisions to grant him protection and not to charge him fell within the exercise of his office's discretion, notwithstanding the continuation of a promise he had made, the Court said in a statement.

The petitioners, it continued, did not specify the "alien objectives" on the basis of which they claimed the police acted and did not provide any evidence of an agreement between Hajigeorgiou and the Legal Service. Moreover, they knew Hatzigeorgiou's identity, the content of his confession and that he would not be prosecuted. At the trial, it is noted, they had the opportunity to examine at will both Hadjigeorgiou and the police officers who had questioned him, while they did not request that the Attorney General be examined.

By a majority of 6 to 1, the Court ruled that the fact that the Nicosia Criminal Court had relied on the testimony of an accomplice had not rendered the trial unfair. It also held, unanimously, that there had been no violation of Article 6§1 in relation to the first applicant for the duration of the proceedings (5 years and 9 months), noting that the complexity of these proceedings justified their somewhat long duration.



In his dissenting opinion, Judge Sergidis cites the Court's case-law and says that he finds a violation of Article 6§1 of the Convention and would award the applicants monetary compensation for non-material damage and costs, but says that this amount need not be determined as his opinion is in the minority.

Source: CNA


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source
 
Back
Top